My endeavor to understand the meaning of
"intolerance" in its totality made me open a dictionary and what I
saw has left me aghast & deeply hurt. Intolerance means "unwillingness
or refusal to tolerate or respect persons of a different social group, especially
members of a minority group." I am shocked and appalled that learned and
highly articulate Muslim friends such as Kabir Khan uses this word
"intolerance" without even thinking once for the MAJORITY of HINDUS
like me. He conveniently forgets the fact that more than 80% of the total
population that resides in this country are Hindus. And if the HUGE majority of
these Hindus were not TOLERANT he would not have achieved the success that he
has.
He puts forth his view point by forwarding the case of three
FILM ICONS. Like millions of indians, I too have immense love and respect for
the three of them. For me they are India's flagbearers in the field of Art
& Entertainment. But Mr. Kabir Khan by bringing them in such partisan
context, you have made me realize that, in your eyes, they are MUSLIMS first
and Indians later. You use them to quote the happenings of the recent past to
further your point and I would not like to go in detail of them as that is
beyond the purview of this topic. But you conveniently forget the simple fact
that they are 1-2-3 of Indian cinema and what they say & when they say is
very closely followed by a large section of the society. And obviously if they
say something which borders sensationalism or which is irresponsible there is
bound to be repercussions. Why only them. Even the Prime Minister of India
faces flak lot of times. Have you seen the educated Hindus up in arms to
counter the unwanted flak he
receives? No. You know why? BECAUSE
HINDUISM IS ONE OF THE MOST TOLERANT RELIGION OF THIS WORLD. Could you or
the likes of you (aka fascist Hindus/Muslims/Sikhs/Christians) make such
utterances outside of India say in a USA or a UK or a Germany or any
middle-eastern country against the majority?
You get upset when the art & cultural activities with
Pakistan stops after a terrorist attack. And you register your protest in
public. Do you even know what your unwarranted utterance does to the cultural
fabric of India? It incites Hindu Muslim alike against each other. Tell me one
thing. When there was a terrorist attack in France, the French didn't wait to
initiate dialogue with ISIS or for that matter Syria. They just went ahead and
pounded and pounded Syria for two full days. Americans destroyed Afghanistan after
9/11. Mind you, sadly, INNOCENT people too lost their lives in such attacks but
they went on and on. And in our country you regret not being able to enjoy bon
homie with Pakistan? Shame on you. Are you out of your senses? A brave INDIAN
soldier dies. His young daughter suddenly becomes fatherless and his wife a
widow. And instead of looking at that or talking about it, you regret not
having an evening of Ghazals !!! You should be thankful that you are in a
country which is tolerant in nature. I dare you to utter these things in USA or
a UK. Let us see how tolerant would they be. I have immense respect for ISLAM
as a religion but I love my religion too. And I would not allow you and your
likes to go scot free for making comments which could be perceived as ANTI INDIA, ANTI ISLAM and ANTI HINDU. Your
marrying a Hindu woman doesn't give you a license to blurt expletives against
my community.
You are a celebrity. Millions follow and appreciate your
film which is very obvious from the box office analysis. But then you
selectively prefer to suffer from anmesia and only remember what certain fringe
elements say. You do not see the praise a common Hindu gives to an Aamir or a
Salman or SRK. You do not see the euphoria that gets created when a Gherua song
is released. All you see is misguided youth directing ill against you in the
social media. Sometimes I feel all this is done to get maximum mileage to
further the cause of a film. Do not
worry Mr. Khan and do not stoop to such cheap levels of publicity. Indian crowd
(Hindu & Muslim inclusive) is very smart and will throng theaters if the
film touches some chords.
Let me remind you as to what happened when PK released and Aamir Khan faced issues
from a certain miniscule section of my community. The majority came out in
hordes and the result is history. PK
is number 1 as far as the box office return go. Even Hindu GODMAN such as Sri
sri sri Ravi Shankar supported him and the film. Our PM, presently the most powerful
man in this country, could have easily put roadblocks for the film if his
thinking matched with those of the select few. Did he do anything to harm the movie?
A BIG NO. See the positives and be happy.
Understand the fact that fascists are on both sides. They should at best be
ignored. Do not try to become one with them. It shows you in very bad light.
The likes of you & SRK, from your positon of power,
should instead be talking about poverty alienation, development, Improvement in
basic infrastructure & Education. Please come out of your virtual space
which is full of unwarranted complexes and irrational thoughts. Let us then
together talk of Development & Infrastructure which the people of this
country badly needs. And when I say people I mean HINDU, MUSLIM, SIKH,
CHRISTIANS, BUDHISTS and others. Let us give a promise to this great motherland
of ours that we, the educated lot, will only talk sense with the single point
agenda to turn her into a country of repute in the true sense.
8 comments:
Very well written Shashank!
Shashank..well written
I agreed with you. Continued post your thoughts.
Really nice article shashank......
"if the HUGE majority of these Hindus were not TOLERANT he would not have achieved the success that he has."
Great thoughts towards the matter...these thoughts and ideas are touchable.
thanks.
Some people may say who the hell gives a damn to what Kabir Khan has to say! But not giving back to him will be as irresponsible as his statement itself. For any community, minor or major, such statements can be disorienting.
I appreciate your sharp response which mostly restricts to contradictory examples from his own fraternity which indeed shall be a befitting reply to such irresponsible statements.
theres been no change in the intolerance level over centuries.. its been the same all along... no change.. intolerant or not is just a point of view based on the political horizons...
people may say many things.. nothing has change.. and a few idiots saying idiotic things wont change anything
Post a Comment